Friday, February 26, 2016

New Report Card: Greater Percentage of Urban Buildings Meet High-Quality Charter Definition Than Charters

There has been lots of discussion recently about how many charter schools meet the state's definition of a "high-quality" school. The primary state "high-quality" definition is a school with a student growth grade of A or B on the state report card and a performance index (proficiency) grade of C or higher. There are a couple other types of definitions (allowing a charter to receive a B or higher on student growth while showing three years of improvement on performance index, even if it's below a C). But if we want to look at the most exclusive definition, it is the A or B in growth and at least a C in performance index.

Even though about 1/2 of charter students do not come from the state's Big 8 Urban districts (Akron, Canton, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, Dayton, Toledo, Youngstown), I thought it might be illuminating to use the new state report cards to see how many charters and how many Big 8 urban buildings meet that most exclusive definition.

The results are fascinating.

There are 33 Big 8 Urban buildings that meet that definition, representing 8% of all Big 8 buildings. Those 33 buildings do not include any district-sponsored charter schools.  Meanwhile, only 14 of 288 charters (including district sponsored ones) that receive report card grades would qualify. That's a rate of 5%. There are about 100 more charters in Ohio, but they are evaluated under a different system.

So the state's urban districts produce high-quality buildings at a 60% greater rate than the state's charter schools, which only have about 1/2 of their students coming from those urban districts.

And here's how the highest performing buildings in each sector perform:

High-quality urban buildings produce 60% As and Bs on the report card. High-quality charters produce 55% As and Bs. But it is on the other end of the scale where the performance difference is most profound. That's because while 16.6% of high-quality urban building grades are Ds and Fs, an astonishing 28% of high-quality charter grades are Ds and Fs.

What this is meant to show is something pretty simple: While high-performing charters are out there and are doing amazing things, there are even more high-performing Big 8 Urban buildings that are also doing amazing things. And it's time we recognize their accomplishments as often and vigorously as we're willing to correctly acknowledge high-performing charter school accomplishments.

And while only having 8% of Big 8 buildings meet this most exclusive "high-quality" definition is still far too infrequent, the fact is it's about a 60% more frequent occurrence than in Ohio's charter schools.

What else is interesting that those 33 high-quality buildings come from 5 of the Big 8 districts.

Number of High-Quality Buildings

So while it's encouraging that kids in most of Ohio's urban districts do have some high-quality options, there remain too few in too few districts.


  1. Really nice information. It is very useful and informative post. Thanks for sharing.
    mobile app for schools in india

  2. The web log and also their work that has been very well furnished with and the service that has been secure area unit too nice for all. In this web site I found some valuable data concerning the education resource that's terribly useful for each student.

  3. Thanks for such quite useful writing. I’ve beloved what ever you've got written in your post and its very useful. Go here and that they all square measure very proverbial to any or all people and for this website can be the proper place.

  4. I’m glad you write of this even within the powerful world things in an exceedingly novel. i like your writing, thanks for the giveaway. This individuals perpetually provide you with the nice service on your writing that you wished.

  5. There is the new report card for your time with the help of which you can find the best settlement. You can also get the true link of your time here and can find which can really make your time more good.

  6. The new report card is waiting for you in this special zone. You can also enjoy the greater area of percentage here. Get the best definition with and find the real pace of your life with the true image.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.