Monday, February 27, 2017

Private School Vouchers Don't Mean More Kids for Private Schools

State Sen Matt Huffman, R-Lima, introduced legislation recently to create statewide vouchers for any family who meets at least 400% of poverty (for a family of four, that's about $100,000, or roughly 81% of Ohio families).

I have always had serious constitutional concerns about Huffman's plan, as I've enumerated on several occasions.

In a nutshell, the U.S. Supreme Court found that Cleveland's voucher program did not violate the Establishment Clause in 2002 because it was small in scope and scale (about $7 million) and was designed to "rescue" kids from "failing schools". However, now the program reaches nearly every school district in the state, including districts that cannot be argued to be "failing" kids. And it's approaching a $250 million program that would be available to more than 80% of Ohio's school children under Huffman's bill.

Aside from this concern, however, is the fascinating fact that since Ohio started funding private, mostly religious school vouchers in 1995-1996, enrollment in private schools has plummeted by nearly 30% to a 40-year low.

In fact, as a percentage of public school enrollment (including charters), private school enrollment is now as small as it's ever been -- less than 10% from a high of more than 13% in the mid-1990s.

What does this mean for Huffman's bill? I don't know. But what the data show pretty convincingly is the more vouchers parents have at their disposal, the fewer students become enrolled in private, mostly religious schools.

Which begs the question: Have vouchers helped maintain private, mostly religious schools' survival, or have they actually hurt private school enrollment?

Only time will tell. But it's fairly clear that if Sen. Huffman is trying to save Ohio's private, mostly religious schools, increased numbers of vouchers do not appear to do the trick.


  1. Really nice information. It is very useful and informative post. Thanks for sharing.
    school parent communication app india

  2. Thanks for giving the chance to read this post. When the things are related to the mystery site then it would have excitement. I think this guide of will help you on the student transcript for the college time as somehow it looks tough to someone.

  3. It would really help those writing examinees improve their writing skills to have a top score on the writing exam. Check more here Essay test will help you to check for more info about how good you are at your writing side and this test will help you to achieve it.

  4. Those whole writing will really make things more fine and the whole things will inspirational. look here and it will tell you about our regular work on personal statements.

  5. This is very important to read for so many people who love driving.I think its best topic for debate on this page forum.Thank you for sharing such amazing idea.

  6. Its really fabulous post.Your ideas always help me when I start working on assignments.Its just remarkable experience.Thank you.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.